Would a movie Velociraptor win or lose against 3 real raptors? (a "you decide" I guess)
11,567 Views28 RepliesAdd A Reply
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-09-2019 2:43 PMWho would win in a battle between a velociraptor from movies like Jurassic Park/World and three realistic, turkey-sized velociraptors? This is basically a "You decide" topic...
I like velociraptors.
Tyrannosaurus RexMember8212 XPNov-09-2019 3:01 PMI would think the velociraptor would win. It is bigger and stronger and could probably stun one while stomping on another so it could strike to kill the third. If there were 6 vicious raptors though, the tables might turn.
I would still think the velociraptor could easilly out run them if it decided to disengage.
Winner by either strength and size or by attrition- Velociraptor.
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-09-2019 3:07 PMInteresting.
I was thinking 2, but 3 can't even do it XD
Maybe I should write a battle with 6 vs 1?
Tyrannosaurus RexMember8212 XPNov-09-2019 3:09 PMNo need to rewrite. Let people weigh in- there might be some interesting answers!
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-09-2019 3:16 PMMk.
I do like me some answers
AllosaurusMember4458 XPNov-10-2019 6:53 PMdk which velociraptor? because the smaller Raptors are the true velociraptors. If you are refering to the big one that is not a velociraptor, velociraptors are NOT BIG! That is a Dakotaraptor!
TLDR
True Velociraptors are the small guys
Movie Velociraptors are actually based off of a Deinochyus, Utahraptor, and later Dakotaraptors. NOT VELOCIRAPTORS
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-10-2019 7:19 PMYeah, I know. I just refer to them as "Velociraptors" because that's what they call them and I don't what too much confusion, I guess? I know they aren't that big.
I should know my velociraptors well...
Tyrannosaurus RexMember8212 XPNov-10-2019 7:54 PMXenotaris I am not well versed with dinos. I was just going with the OP and a very basic Wikki lookup.
VelociraptorMember1630 XPNov-10-2019 8:08 PMXenotaris
Not to be that guy, but you're still a little wrong. I think Flyleaf means the Velociraptors in Jurassic Park, which although inaccurate, are canonically Velociraptors. Second of all, they're not Dakotaraptors. Sure, they're in the same size range, but they're Velociraptors, and they were actually based off of Deinonychus. Dakotaraptor wasn't discovered until a few years ago, let along by 1993.
But to answer the original topic, the JP Velociraptor wins for a variety of reasons. First of all, it has problem solving intelligence, while an actual Velociraptor only has about the intelligence of a turkey (figures). JP Velociraptor is MUCH larger, and somehow incredibly quick, agile, and can leap much higher than I think the average REAL Velociraptor can. Third, actual Velociraptors probably weren't actually pack hunters, at least I haven't really heard of any substantial evidence of it. They probably wouldn't be very well coordinated either. Fourth, JP Velociraptors are incredibly strong for their size, strong enough to actually do some damage to the Indominus in Jurassic World, despite its really tough hide, and to Tyrannosaurus. They technically may be able to bring down the JP Spinosaurus too, because that was part of the original script for JP3, but that isn't canon so it's not really worth mentioning. I mean, this isn't really fair. It's like pitting 3 chicken against an emu or a cassowary lol
If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-10-2019 8:17 PMWelp
Tyrannosaurus RexMember8212 XPNov-10-2019 8:50 PMThis is starting to sound like The Holy Grail lol:
AllosaurusMember4458 XPNov-10-2019 10:14 PMTheLazyFish and Flyleaf-Rapt0r That comment was for dk
Tyrannosaurus RexMember9516 XPNov-10-2019 11:22 PMSimple answer,
The real raptors would win because the movie Raptor isn't real, it's just a movie monster.
The same argument goes for a real T. Rex with feathers et al, and the JP T. Rex.
AllosaurusMember4458 XPNov-10-2019 11:24 PM
I did mention they were based on Deinonychus first. I just added that latter portrayals they were given attributes of other dromaeosaurids
VelociraptorMember1630 XPNov-11-2019 12:33 AMWell, specifically you said they were based off of Deinonychus, Utahraptor, and Dakotaraptor... but that's impossible because Utahraptor and Dakotaraptor hadn't been discovered yet, so I thought you meant they're more like those guys. Sorry, I guess I misunderstood.
If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.
VelociraptorMember1630 XPNov-11-2019 12:34 AMGavin
Well by that logic, a mosquito could kill Godzilla.
If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.
AllosaurusMember4458 XPNov-11-2019 1:50 AMI am well aware that the Utahraptor was discovered during the filming of the original Jurassic Park and was named two years later and that the Dakotaraptor was named in 2015
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-11-2019 5:39 AMCan we stop talking about my choice of what I called the dinosaur and get on topic please...?
AllosaurusMember4458 XPNov-11-2019 12:32 PMSorry, ummm the genetically altered Velociraptor due to size and intelligence. Kind of unfair advantage
VelociraptorMember1789 XPNov-11-2019 4:07 PMBig Velociraptor takes it.
Zwei Wing is the best singing duo. Change my mind.
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-11-2019 4:25 PMMk I'm sure the debate is over now XD
JK though. I'm gonna say the JP raptors wins now.
VelociraptorMember1630 XPNov-11-2019 5:43 PMThe debate was over before it even started lol
If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-11-2019 5:46 PMw h e l p
TriceratopsMember328 XPNov-12-2019 11:02 AMA decent (You Decide) topic.Just because you make good battles that aren't (You Decide) topics.
"I hope,one day,i will go to the U.S.A..."
Ganimes V.8,December 10th 2019
TriceratopsMember328 XPNov-12-2019 11:03 AMThe Real raptors win,because 3 are better than 1.
"I hope,one day,i will go to the U.S.A..."
Ganimes V.8,December 10th 2019
VelociraptorMember1630 XPNov-12-2019 11:58 AMGanimes V.8
By that logic, 3 house flies can kill Godzilla
If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.
BrachiosaurusMember1449 XPNov-12-2019 12:12 PMI prefer realistic raptors over movie ones, but I still love JP/W raptors.
VelociraptorMember1630 XPNov-12-2019 2:01 PMSo do I. I prefer Dakotaraptors to the JP Velociraptors, but JP Velociraptors are still cool. Still, a JP Velociraptors would absolutely wreck 3 real Velociraptors lol
If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.
StegosaurusMember968 XPNov-12-2019 2:23 PMJP Velociraptor wins because it is too strong and too big. It will kill all of the other raptors.
